Skip to content
February 4, 2014 / Leslie

Review: The Supreme Macaroni Company by Adriana Trigiani

Supreme Macaroni CompanyThe Supreme Macaroni Company
by Adriana Trigiani
Narrated by Cassandra Campbell

Genre: Women’s Fiction
Publisher: HarperAudio
Publish Date: November 26, 2013
Format: Audio, 11 hours | 8 minutes
Audio Listening Level: Easy – Intermediate
Rating: 3 of 5

Publisher’s Synopsis:

For over a hundred years, the Angelini Shoe Company in Greenwich Village has relied on the leather produced by Vechiarelli & Son in Tuscany. This historic business partnership provides the twist of fate for Valentine Roncalli, the school teacher turned shoemaker, to fall in love with Gianluca Vechiarelli, a tanner with a complex past … and a secret.

My Thoughts:

This is book three in the Valentine series, although you wouldn’t guess it from the title, and initially I thought it was a standalone story. About half-way through we finally learn the meaning, but it still felt like an odd choice for the title.

In the first two books, Very Valentine and Brava Valentine, Valentine Roncalli was portrayed as a mature, determined young woman working hard to save the family’s shoe business and at the same time balancing family and personal life with her career. In the third book, Valentine’s character has changed. It’s as if falling in love with Gianluca has messed up her brain. She is no longer a strong, wise young woman and has become whiny and insecure.

A whirlwind wedding can be believable but most couples know each other well enough to discuss some very important issues before running to the alter; especially subjects like children, where to live, careers, and family history. Marriage is a big step and Valentine didn’t understand that many parts of her life would change. It wasn’t very believable that two people who weren’t young kids, and that already had much life experience, would not bother to talk about these things and then argue about it later. (I suppose I shouldn’t look for reality in my romance reading, but I keep searching).

Despite my disappointment in Valentine, I thoroughly enjoyed her large Italian family, the witty conversations and the beautiful descriptions of Italy. Coming from a Tuscan Italian family myself, I can attest that the descriptions have a delightful air of authenticity, albeit a little overblown. This is where the author is at her best and it makes this a book worth reading.

One last thought, and with no spoilers, was that I did not like the ending and am hoping for another book in the series. While many loose ends were tied up, a lot more openings were created.

Audio Production: The audio was read by the excellent Cassandra Campbell. Her changes in vocalization for the many different characters made it easy for me to tell them apart. Listeners need to stay alert for a few jumps forward in time, but otherwise, an easy listen.

Source: Review copy provided by HarperAudio
© 2014 Under My Apple Tree. All rights reserved.
Advertisements appearing on this site are placed by WordPress and are not endorsed or approved by me.



Leave a Comment
  1. Mary / Feb 4 2014 1:43 pm

    I was surprised by the title. Why not something involving “Valentine”? I also hope for another book. Perhaps 10 years down the road.


    • Leslie / Feb 4 2014 1:49 pm

      I loved The Shoemaker’s Wife and when I heard there was a new book by Adriana Trigiani I assumed from the title that it was a new series or stand-alone, so I requested a copy. When it arrived I was surprised to find it was book 3 of Valentine. I should read descriptions a little more closely but I like the author so I just went for it.


  2. BermudaOnion / Feb 4 2014 2:24 pm

    Yeah, I’m not sure why they titled it the way they did but I still loved this book. I enjoyed Valentine and her family and miss them!


    • Leslie / Feb 4 2014 2:37 pm

      We definitely need another book in the series.


  3. Suko / Feb 4 2014 6:46 pm

    The title of this book is “catchy”, even if it doesn’t quite fit. Thanks for your honest review of this audiobook, Leslie. I’ll read (or listen to) this series when I have time!


    • Leslie / Feb 4 2014 7:15 pm

      It is catchy even if Valentine doesn’t open a pasta factory!


  4. irene / Feb 4 2014 8:21 pm

    I haven’t read any of this series, even though I do have a couple on the TBR pile. thanks for your thoughts.


  5. Jennifer @ The Relentless Reader / Feb 4 2014 8:30 pm

    Oh! I’ve been curious about this one but I had no idea it was part of a series!


  6. Diane@BibliophilebytheSea / Feb 4 2014 9:05 pm

    Haven’t read this one yet. Sorry it was so so for you.


  7. stacybuckeye / Feb 7 2014 9:49 pm

    It’s actually nice to read a less than fawning review. Everyone seems to love this series so much. One day…


Comment are welcome. Thanks for stopping by.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: